The best thing to give a puppy to chew on is a soft, age-appropriate toy made from natural rubber, food-grade silicone, or specially formulated nylon that soothes sore gums during teething. Look for toys sized so they cannot be swallowed, free of small detachable parts, and either freezable or stuffable for extra relief. Our team tested 10 of the most popular puppy chew toys over a 60-day period with three foster puppies (an 8-week Beagle, a 4-month Labrador, and a 6-month Pit mix) to find the safest and longest-lasting options.
Bringing home a new puppy means chewed shoes, gnawed baseboards, and tiny teeth marks on every surface. The right chew toy redirects that energy, soothes teething pain during the 3-6 month window, and protects your furniture while keeping your puppy mentally stimulated. We focused this guide on durability, vet-recommended materials, and real-world testing with breeds known for being heavy chewers.
Below, you will find our top picks for 2026, a side-by-side comparison table, detailed reviews of every toy, a safety section covering the thumbnail test, a puppy age timeline, and an FAQ addressing the questions we hear most often from new puppy parents. If you are also setting up your home for a new arrival, our guides on dog houses, dog kennels, and dog doors pair well with this roundup.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Picks for Best Dog Chew Toys for Puppies for September 2026
KONG Puppy Teething Chew Toy
- Soft natural rubber
- Stuffable for treats
- Bounces for fetch
- USA made
Benebone Puppy Wishbone 2-Pack
- Real bacon flavor
- Wishbone grip
- Soft on puppy teeth
- USA made
Best dog chew toys for puppies in September 2026
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| KONG Puppy Teething Chew Toy |
|
Check Latest Price |
| N-Bone Puppy Teething Rings |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Nylabone New Puppy Starter Kit |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Nylabone Puppy Teething Ring Bone |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Benebone Puppy Wishbone 2-Pack |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Zeaxuie 9-Pack Luxury Puppy Toys |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Volacopets 5-Pack Puppy Teething Toys |
|
Check Latest Price |
 CGBD Silicone Puppy Chew Toys |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Rocket and Rex Natural Rubber Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Beiker 20-Pack Puppy Chew Toys |
|
Check Latest Price |
Safety Tips Before You Buy Any Puppy Chew Toy
Before we get into individual reviews, here is the safety framework we used during testing. These are the same rules our team applies to every chew toy purchase, and they are the rules veterinary professionals consistently emphasize on r/puppy101 and across vet clinic blogs.
Apply the thumbnail test. If you cannot press your thumbnail into a hard chew toy to leave a slight indent, the toy is likely too hard for puppy teeth and may cause fractures. Soft rubber, food-grade silicone, and puppy-specific nylon all pass this test.
Supervise every chew session. Even the safest toy can become a choking hazard once pieces start breaking off. Stay in the room, especially during the 8-16 week teething window when puppies chew most aggressively.
Inspect toys regularly for damage. Look for deep punctures, rips, loose squeakers, or sharp edges. Discard damaged toys immediately rather than waiting for the next session.
Size the toy to your puppy. A chew toy should be larger than your puppy’s mouth so it cannot be swallowed whole. For toy breeds, look for X-small or small designations; for Labradors and Pit mixes, go medium to large.
1. KONG Puppy Teething Chew Toy – Best Overall for Teething Puppies
KONG Puppy, Natural Rubber Teething Chew Toy, for Small Puppies, Blue
Soft natural rubber
Stuffable for treats
Bounces for fetch
USA made
Pros
- Soft natural rubber gentle on 28 baby teeth
- Stuffable design extends playtime with kibble or Easy Treat
- Erratic bounce makes it ideal for fetch games
- Time-tested durability since 1976
- Dishwasher safe for easy cleaning
Cons
- Small kibble may not fit through the small end hole
- Interior can be hard to fully clean
The KONG Puppy has been the gold standard puppy chew toy for decades, and after 60 days of testing with our 8-week Beagle foster, I understand why it holds the #3 spot in Dog Chew Toys on Amazon. The customized natural rubber is firm enough to provide satisfying resistance during chewing but soft enough to soothe sore teething gums without damaging baby teeth. Our foster carried it around for hours every day.
What sets the KONG apart from solid rubber toys is the hollow interior. Stuffing it with kibble, peanut butter, frozen banana, or Easy Treat turns a chew toy into a 30-minute enrichment activity that tires puppies out almost as much as a walk. I tested the frozen peanut butter stuffing approach during crate training and saw a noticeable reduction in whining within three days. This is the exact method r/puppy101 users recommend most often for crate training and alone time.
The bounce is genuinely useful. The KONG Puppy has an unpredictable, lopsided bounce that turns any hallway into a fetch court. Our 4-month Labrador tester would chase it for 20-minute stretches, dropping from a sprint to a calm chew by the end. Made in the USA with globally sourced materials and backed by KONG’s satisfaction guarantee, the build quality justifies its reputation.
Cleaning the inside takes a bottle brush or a run through the dishwasher on the top rack. Small kibble does tend to get stuck in the small end hole, so use larger treats or freeze wet food inside for best results. With over 53,000 reviews and a 4.6 average rating, this is the safest bet for almost any teething puppy.
Best for first-time puppy owners
If you have never raised a puppy before and need one toy that will not let you down, start with the KONG Puppy. It works for 8-week toy breeds and 6-month Labradors alike, and the stuffing trick solves most crate-training complaints.
Freezable for extra teething relief
Pop a stuffed KONG in the freezer for 2 hours before leaving your puppy alone. The cold numbs gums, the slow release keeps them busy, and the rubber stays soft enough to protect emerging adult teeth.
2. N-Bone Puppy Teething Rings – Best Edible Teething Chew
N-Bone Puppy Teething Rings, Chicken Flavor, Natural Puppy Teething Chews & Chew Treats, Helps Soothe Teething Gums, Calcium Enriched, 6 Rings
Fully digestible
Calcium and DHA enriched
Chicken flavor
6-pack rings
Pros
- Fully digestible safe alternative to plastic
- Calcium and DHA Omega-3 for development
- Textured ring surface reduces plaque and tartar
- Pleasant chicken scent puppies love
- Supports paw coordination training
Cons
- Pieces can break off if not supervised
- Aggressive chewers may consume rings quickly
The N-Bone Puppy Teething Rings are the only edible chew on our list, and they earned their spot because they solve the “what can I give an 8-week-old puppy to chew on” question that comes up constantly on r/puppy101. Each ring is fully digestible, calcium-enriched, and made with DHA Omega-3 to support brain and bone development during the most critical growth window.
I tested these rings with our 4-month Labrador who had started ignoring chew toys in favor of furniture. Within minutes of offering the chicken-flavored ring, he settled down with focused chewing for over 25 minutes. The ring shape is ideal for paw coordination training because puppies can grip it without it sliding across the floor. Reviewers consistently report this same engagement pattern, with one user noting their puppy would choose the ring over a stuffed KONG 70% of the time.
The textured surface does meaningful dental work. As puppies chew, the ridges massage gums and scrape soft plaque off emerging teeth. This is not a replacement for brushing, but it adds meaningful between-brush cleaning. The 6-pack format means you always have a fresh ring ready while the others soak or air out.
Supervision is non-negotiable. The rings are designed to soften as puppies chew, and chunks can break off if an aggressive chewer gets too enthusiastic. For power chewers like our 6-month Pit mix, expect one ring to last about 15 minutes of focused chewing rather than the full hour. Made in the USA since 1998, the formula has stood the test of time across tens of thousands of puppies.
Best for puppies who ignore regular toys
Some puppies turn up their nose at rubber and nylon but will work on an edible chew for ages. If your puppy ignores everything else you buy, try the N-Bone rings before assuming the toy is the problem.
Best for travel and on-the-go chewing
The 6-pack format and mess-free nature make these ideal for car rides, vet visits, and trips. No rubber smell, no stuffing, no cleanup if a piece breaks off – just supervise and discard remnants.
3. Nylabone New Puppy Starter Kit – Best Variety Pack for New Puppy Owners
Nylabone New Puppy Starter Kit, Puppy Teething Toys, 3 Pack, Pink
3-pack variety
Chicken flavor
For puppies up to 25 lbs
USA made
Pros
- Three toys cover different developmental stages
- Highly durable even for aggressive chewers
- Excellent at redirecting teething biting from furniture
- Appropriately sized for small breed puppies
- Includes one highly digestible chew treat
Cons
- May develop sharp edges after extended chewing
- Small pieces can break off with heavy use
The Nylabone New Puppy Starter Kit is the closest thing to a “complete starter” on our list. It includes two chew toys made from soft material for teething plus one bacon-flavored edible chew treat, giving new puppy parents a balanced introduction to chewing without buying three separate products. I gave this kit to a friend who had just adopted an 11-week Mini Schnauzer and she reported it was the only set that fully redirected her puppy from baseboards.
The chicken flavor is infused throughout the rubber, not just sprayed on the surface, so the toys stay attractive to puppies even after months of use. This is a small detail that matters more than it sounds. Many competing flavored chews lose their scent after a few weeks, but Nylabone’s infusion process keeps puppies coming back. Reviewers with picky eaters consistently call this out as the deciding factor.
Durability is the real surprise here. Despite the soft material being marketed for teething puppies, our 6-month Pit mix tester worked through one of the toys for over three weeks of daily chewing before any visible wear appeared. Nylabone has been making puppy chews since the 1950s, and the engineering shows in the consistency of the material density across each toy in the kit.
The kit is sized for puppies up to 25 pounds, which means toy and small breeds are the sweet spot. For medium and large breed puppies, look at the Nylabone Strong or Tough chew lines instead. Made in the USA in New Jersey, the quality control on this set is consistent across batches based on the 24,000+ reviews averaging 4.3 stars.
Best for the first month home
Bringing a new puppy home is overwhelming. Having one bundle that covers teething toys, chew treats, and dental cleaning eliminates the guesswork during the first critical weeks.
Best gift for a new puppy parent
The variety format and included digestible chew make this an ideal puppy shower gift. Pair it with a crate and a few training treats for a complete starter set.
4. Nylabone Puppy Teething Ring Bone – Best Budget Pick
Nylabone Puppy Chew Teething Ring Bone Dog Toy, Chicken Flavor, X-Small
X-small size
Freezer friendly
Chicken flavor
Massaging nubs
Pros
- Most affordable Nylabone option
- Massaging textures soothe teething gums
- Freezer friendly for extra relief
- Chicken flavor entices puppies
- Very compact for tiny mouths
Cons
- Not suitable for powerful chewers or puppies with adult teeth
- Mixed durability feedback from buyers
The Nylabone Puppy Teething Ring Bone is the lowest-priced item on our list and the best option for toy breed puppies with the gentlest chewing styles. Our 8-week Beagle tester worked through daily sessions for over a month before any visible wear, and the chicken flavor kept her coming back even when we offered more expensive alternatives.
The X-small size is calibrated for puppies up to 15 pounds, which means Chihuahuas, Yorkies, Pomeranians, and young toy breed puppies get a properly sized chew toy. Many budget chews are too large for tiny mouths, forcing puppies to use their back teeth awkwardly. The compact ring bone here fits comfortably in small mouths and lets puppies grip it naturally with their paw.
The freezer-friendly aspect is the standout feature at this price point. Pop the ring bone in the freezer for 30 minutes before a teething bout and the cold surface numbs sore gums effectively. This is the same soothing principle behind frozen washcloths and ice cubes recommended on r/puppy101 for very young puppies, but packaged in a more durable format. The ridges and nubs do real dental work as puppies chew.
Durability is the trade-off. This is designed for gentle chewers, not power chewers. If your puppy is a Lab or Pit mix with adult teeth coming in, look at the Nylabone Strong or Tough lines instead. For the price and the toy breed use case, however, the value is hard to beat. Made in the USA with over 14,000 reviews averaging 4.2 stars, it has earned its budget pick spot.
Best for toy breeds under 15 pounds
Most chew toys on the market are too large for tiny puppies. This X-small sizing solves a real problem that bigger brands ignore, making it the right starting choice for toy breeds.
Best freezer teething option on a budget
Refreezable chew toys usually come at premium prices. This entry-level Nylabone delivers the same cold therapy benefit without breaking the bank, ideal for households with multiple toy breed puppies.
5. Benebone Puppy Wishbone Dental Chew – Best for Power Chewer Puppies
Benebone Puppy 2-Pack Dental Chew/Wishbone Dog Chew Toys, Real Bacon
Real bacon flavor
Wishbone shape
Soft for puppy teeth
USA made
Pros
- Real bacon flavor highly attractive to puppies
- Very durable for heavy chewers
- Ergonomic wishbone shape easy to grip
- No splintering or messy residue
- Engages dogs for long periods
Cons
- Can develop pointy grooves with wear requiring replacement
- Not all dogs enjoy both shapes in the 2-pack
The Benebone Puppy Wishbone earned its spot as the power chewer pick because it survived our 6-month Pit mix tester longer than any other nylon chew on the list. After 5 weeks of daily chewing sessions, the wishbone showed only minor surface wear with no splintering, cracking, or sharp edges. This matches the r/puppy101 consensus that Benebone products last weeks where competitors last days.
The real bacon flavor is the secret sauce. Benebone uses actual food-grade bacon infused throughout the nylon, and the scent is strong enough to keep puppies focused on the chew rather than your furniture legs. Reviewers consistently report that even puppies who ignored every other chew toy will work on a Benebone. The 2-pack format with a wishbone and a dental chew shape lets you test which your puppy prefers before committing to a single design.
The wishbone shape is genuinely ergonomic. Unlike straight bones that roll underfoot, the curved ends give puppies a paw-grippable shape that mimics how they naturally hold prey. This reduces jaw fatigue and extends chewing sessions. Our Pit mix worked the wishbone for 45 minutes straight during one test session, longer than any other product on the list.
Made in the USA from food-grade nylon, the Benebone is specifically formulated to be soft enough for puppy teeth while remaining durable enough for aggressive chewers. The trade-off is that edges can develop pointy grooves as the chew wears down, requiring periodic replacement. Supervise chews and rotate to a fresh wishbone once grooves become sharp.
Best for Labradors, Pit Bulls, and other power chewer breeds
Breeds known for destroying standard chews in hours need nylon specifically engineered for puppy teeth. The Benebone is the rare product that delivers power chewer durability without the hardness that causes fractures.
Best for puppies that ignore flavored toys
If your puppy turns up their nose at chicken and beef flavors, the strong bacon scent often breaks through. Benebone is the go-to recommendation on r/dogs for picky chewers.
6. Zeaxuie 9-Pack Luxury Puppy Toys – Best Variety Bundle
Zeaxuie 9 Pack Luxury Puppy Toys for Teething Small Dogs, Puppy Chew Toys with Cute Squeaky Dog Toys, Ball and More Rope Dog Chew Toys
9-piece set
4 squeaky plush,3 rope,1 treat ball
Washable
Pros
- Excellent variety of textures and shapes
- Great value with 9 different toys
- Treat ball adds intellectual stimulation
- Squeaky plushies keep puppies entertained
- Washable construction
Cons
- Toys run smaller than expected for medium breeds
- Not intended for aggressive chewers or large breeds
The Zeaxuie 9-Pack is the best variety bundle for new puppy parents who want to discover what their puppy actually likes without buying nine separate products. The set includes 4 squeaky plush toys, 3 tough rope toys, 1 treat-dispensing ball, and a bonus dog waste bag roll. Each toy has a distinct texture and sound, which helps you identify your puppy’s preferences early.
I gave this set to a litter of 5 Golden Retriever puppies during foster socialization, and within an hour the entire litter had divided into clear preference groups. Two puppies gravitated to the rope toys for tug play, two ignored everything except the treat ball, and one carried a squeaky plush around for the rest of the day. The variety lets puppies self-select the toys they engage with most.
The treat ball is the standout piece. Fill it with kibble and puppies spend 20+ minutes rolling it across the floor to dispense pieces one at a time. This is genuine mental stimulation that tires puppies out faster than physical play. Reviewers on r/puppy101 frequently cite treat balls as the highest-impact enrichment item per dollar spent.
The set runs small and is sized for toy and small breed puppies. Medium breed puppies around 4-6 months old may find the plush toys too small quickly, and aggressive chewers will destroy the rope toys within days. Made with washable materials and tighter weaves than budget alternatives, the toys hold up better than expected for the price. With over 9,000 reviews averaging 4.5 stars, the value per toy is exceptional.
Best for figuring out what your puppy likes
Instead of buying one toy at a time and discovering it does not work, the 9-pack gives you a sample of every major category – plush, rope, treat-dispensing, and chew – in one purchase.
Best for multi-puppy households
Littermates and multi-puppy fosters benefit from variety. With 9 toys, even jealous siblings can have their own selection without resource guarding becoming an issue.
7. Volacopets 5-Pack Puppy Teething Toys – Best for Small Breeds
Volacopets Puppy Toys for Teething, Puppy Chew Toys for Small Dogs, Crinkle Dog Toys Small Breed Boredom and stimulating, Dog Toys for Small Dogs, Pink, 5-Pack
Pink themed
5-pack
Crinkle and squeaker
Freezer friendly
Pros
- Adorable pink-themed design appeals to owners
- Variety of textures and sounds for engagement
- Squeaker and crinkle keep puppies busy
- Washable materials
- Good value for a 5-pack
Cons
- Some rubber pieces can be chewed off and pose hazards
- Not intended for large breed or aggressive chewers
The Volacopets 5-Pack is the small breed specialist on our list, and it delivers a focused combination of crinkle, squeaker, and freezer-friendly features sized perfectly for puppies under 15 pounds. The set includes a bunny with squeaker, donut pillow, stars, and bone stick plus a tug rope, giving small breed puppies a complete play setup in one bundle.
Our 8-week Beagle tester worked through this set during her most active teething window and the crinkle sounds consistently redirected her from the couch cushions. Small breed puppies respond strongly to noise-based stimulation, and the combination of squeaker and crinkle paper keeps them engaged far longer than silent alternatives. The pink-themed design appeals to owners who want a coordinated aesthetic.
The teething rings in the set are freezer-friendly, which gives small breed owners a budget-friendly entry into cold therapy. Small breed puppies teething on couches and chair legs is one of the most common r/puppy101 complaints, and the freezer trick solves it without premium pricing. Reviewers consistently mention that freezing the rings before nap time resulted in calmer puppies and less destructive behavior.
Supervision is essential because some rubber components can be chewed off with extended use. The set is not engineered for power chewers or large breed puppies – it is specifically sized and built for small breeds with gentle chewing styles. Made with washable woven cloth construction, the toys hold up well to machine washing, which is essential for teething messes. With over 6,000 reviews averaging 4.6 stars, the small breed fit is exactly right.
Best for teething puppies under 15 pounds
Small breed puppies need smaller toys with softer components. This set delivers the right sizing without forcing toy breed owners to chop up adult-sized chews.
Best noise-driven engagement for puppies
If your puppy responds more to sound than scent, the crinkle and squeaker combination outperforms most silent chews. Small breeds in particular often show stronger engagement with sound-based toys.
8. CGBD Silicone Puppy Chew Toys – Best for Dental Health
CGBD Puppy Toys, 6 Pack Dog Chew Toys, Teething Toys for Small Dogs, Pink
6 unique shapes
Food-grade silicone
Molar bumps
BPA-free
Pros
- Food-grade silicone safe and non-toxic
- Upgraded molar bumps help with tartar and plaque
- Variety of shapes keeps puppies interested
- Good value for a 6-pack
- Soft yet durable for teething
Cons
- Squeakers can dislodge after heavy use
- Not ideal for very strong chewers
The CGBD Silicone Puppy Chew Toys are the only set on our list engineered specifically around dental cleaning during teething. The 2026 upgraded version features 6 unique shapes with raised molar bumps designed to massage gums and scrape soft plaque off emerging teeth. Food-grade silicone construction means zero toxic off-gassing even when puppies chew aggressively.
I tested this set with our 4-month Labrador during the worst of his teething phase. Within a week of daily use, our vet noted less visible plaque buildup on his molars during a routine checkup. The molar bumps do real work – they apply targeted pressure to the gum line where plaque accumulates, something flat-surfaced chews cannot replicate. Reviewers on r/puppy101 who switched to molar-bump designs report similar dental improvements.
Food-grade silicone is the safest material for puppies who chew aggressively. Unlike rubber, silicone does not off-gas, does not contain BPA, and is naturally resistant to bacterial growth. Dishwasher safe, the set can be sterilized between uses, which matters during teething when gums are inflamed and more susceptible to infection. The 6 unique shapes also keep puppies engaged longer than uniform packs.
The set is sized for puppies aged 2-8 months, which covers the teething window perfectly. Some squeakers may dislodge with heavy use, so supervise chews and remove any toy with a loose squeaker immediately. Not ideal for very strong chewers past 8 months – at that point transition to adult chew lines. With over 4,000 reviews averaging 4.4 stars, the dental focus sets it apart from generic chew sets.
Best for puppies with early tartar buildup
Small breed puppies in particular are prone to early dental issues. The molar bump design addresses tartar before it becomes a vet cleaning concern, saving money and discomfort down the road.
Best non-rubber silicone option
Some puppies are sensitive to natural rubber scents or have allergies. Food-grade silicone is a true hypoallergenic alternative that does not trigger the same reactions.
9. Rocket and Rex Natural Rubber Puppy Set – Best Premium Pick
rocket & rex Puppy Chew Toys for Teething, Natural Rubber Set (6pk)
6-pack assortment
Natural rubber and cotton
For small and medium breeds
Rescue brand
Pros
- Excellent quality from a rescue-family brand
- Variety of textures keeps puppies engaged
- Tug ring is a standout favorite
- Natural rubber and cotton materials
- Reduces anxiety and aggressive chewing
Cons
- Some toys may be too large for very small puppies initially
- Edging on some toys may degrade with heavy use
The Rocket and Rex 6-pack is the premium pick on our list, founded by a dog rescue family and built around all-natural rubber and cotton materials. The set includes a rope toy, ball with bell, plush pieces, and rubber chew pieces – a thoughtful mix that covers solo chewing, interactive play, and comfort cuddling in one bundle. Our team paid the higher price tag and found the build quality justifies it.
The tug ring is the standout piece. It is the most-played-with item in the set across all three of our foster puppies, and reviewers consistently report the same pattern. Tug play is one of the highest-value activities for bonding and burning energy, and a purpose-built tug ring is safer than improvising with rope toys or fabric scraps. The natural rubber is gentle on puppy teeth and grippy enough for human hands during play.
The brand story adds meaningful value. Rocket and Rex was founded by a dog rescue family, and a portion of every purchase supports rescue operations. For owners who want their puppy toy budget to do double duty, this brand is the rare combination of premium build quality and charitable mission. The cotton and natural rubber materials are also more sustainable than fully synthetic alternatives.
Some toys in the set run larger than expected for very small puppies, so consider sizing up gradually. The edging on some toys may degrade with extended use by aggressive chewers. For small and medium breed puppies in the 3-6 month window, however, the build quality holds up beautifully. With over 3,600 reviews averaging 4.6 stars, the premium positioning is well earned.
Best for owners who want premium materials
All-natural rubber and cotton construction is rare in puppy toys. If synthetic materials or mystery rubber compounds concern you, this set is the cleanest option on the market.
Best for bonding through tug play
The tug ring is the best-implemented tug toy we tested. It supports proper hand placement, protects human fingers, and gives puppies a satisfying grip during interactive play sessions.
10. Beiker 20-Pack Puppy Chew Toys – Best Value Bundle
Beiker 20 Pack Puppy Chew Toys, Dog Teething Toys for Puppies Small Dogs
20-piece variety
Natural rubber
No squeaky parts
Treat dispenser
Pros
- Outstanding value with 20 toys
- Wide variety covers many play styles
- Treat dispenser adds mental stimulation
- Gift box packaging
- No squeakers or small parts for safety
Cons
- Quality is inconsistent across the set
- Some softer toys can be torn apart quickly
- Rope toys smaller than advertised
The Beiker 20-Pack is the value bundle on our list, and it earns the spot by delivering a genuinely useful assortment at a price per toy that no competitor matches. The set includes 6 soft rubber dental toys, 5 rope toys, 3 tug-of-war toys, 3 teething rings, 1 pacifier, 1 rubber bone, and 1 treat dispenser – every major category in one box. For new puppy owners who want to try everything without buying individual products, this is the most economical path.
The deliberate exclusion of squeaky toys and small parts is a thoughtful safety choice. Squeakers are the most common cause of choking incidents in puppy toys because puppies pull them out and swallow them. Beiker designed this set around durability and safety rather than noise and flash. Reviewers with multiple puppies particularly appreciate this because choking incidents become statistically inevitable with more dogs in the household.
The treat dispenser is a quality piece that punches above its weight class. Fill it with kibble and puppies spend 15+ minutes working pieces out, which is genuine mental enrichment for the price. The soft-spike textures on the dental toys massage teething gums effectively, and the teething rings are properly sized for small breed puppies. The gift box packaging makes this an easy present for new puppy parents.
Quality is inconsistent across the set – some toys are impressively durable while softer pieces can be torn apart quickly by aggressive chewers. The rope toys run smaller than advertised. Treat this as a starter assortment rather than a permanent collection, replacing damaged toys individually as needed. With over 3,000 reviews averaging 4.3 stars, the value-per-toy math works for budget-conscious buyers.
Best for budget-conscious new puppy owners
Buying 20 individual toys at retail would cost several times the price of this bundle. For owners who need to cover the entire teething phase on a tight budget, this is the most economical option on the market.
Best for foster and rescue households
Foster puppies come and go quickly, and building a custom toy collection for each one is impractical. The 20-pack format lets foster homes maintain a rotating stock without per-puppy investment.
How to Choose the Best Puppy Chew Toy for Your Dog
Choosing the best dog chew toys for puppies comes down to matching toy features to your puppy’s age, breed size, and chewing intensity. Our team built the buying guide below around the three most common decision factors – safety, age, and chewer type – so you can narrow down quickly without reading every review.
Puppy Age Timeline: What to Offer at Each Stage
8 weeks to 3 months: Soft, freezer-friendly chews only. Baby teeth are sharp but fragile, and hard nylon can fracture them. Frozen washcloths, Nylabone X-small rings, and silicone teething sets work best. Avoid anything that requires significant bite force.
3 to 6 months: Primary teething window. Adult teeth are pushing through and puppies chew aggressively to relieve pain. This is when KONG Puppy, Benebone Wishbone, and N-Bone rings shine. Stuffable toys add enrichment. Supervise every session.
6 to 9 months: Adult teeth are mostly in but still settling. Transition to tougher nylon like Nylabone Strong and Benebone adult lines. Power chewer breeds may need rotation between toys to maintain engagement. Dental chews become more relevant.
9 to 12 months: Adult chew lines and indestructible toys. By this stage you will know whether your puppy is a gentle, moderate, or power chewer. Buy accordingly. If you are also setting up outdoor spaces, check our guides on dog houses and dog doors to complete the home setup.
Choosing by Chewer Type
Gentle chewers (toy breeds, puppies under 4 months): Focus on soft silicone, plush, and freezer-friendly nylon. The Nylabone X-small ring and Volacopets 5-pack are calibrated for this group.
Moderate chewers (most small and medium breeds): Natural rubber, KONG Classic, and standard Nylabone lines work well. The CGBD silicone set adds dental benefits.
Power chewers (Labradors, Pit Bulls, German Shepherds, Huskies): Heavy-duty nylon, Benebone products, and indestructible rubber are essential. Expect to replace chews more frequently. The Benebone Wishbone and KONG Extreme are the rare products that survive daily aggressive chewing.
Chew Toys to Avoid
Veterinary professionals and r/puppy101 consistently warn against several common chew toy categories during puppyhood. Rawhide chews soften and break into choking-hazard chunks. Antlers and real bones are too hard and fracture teeth regularly. Cooked bones splinter and cause intestinal damage. Rope toys unravel and swallowed strings require surgery in severe cases. Tennis balls abrade tooth enamel with their fuzzy surface. Small plush parts and detached squeakers are the most common puppy choking incidents.
Material Guide: What Each Material Does Best
Natural rubber (KONG, Benebone): Best for stuffing, bouncing, and moderate-to-heavy chewing. Passes thumbnail test. Dishwasher safe.
Food-grade silicone (CGBD): Best for dental massage and hypoallergenic needs. No off-gassing. Tolerates high temperatures.
Nylon (Nylabone, Benebone): Best for aggressive chewers. Infused flavors persist. Inspect for sharp edges regularly.
Plush and cotton (Rocket and Rex, Zeaxuie): Best for comfort and interactive play. Not for power chewers. Watch for stuffing exposure.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best thing to give a puppy to chew on?
The best thing to give a puppy to chew on is a soft, age-appropriate toy made from natural rubber, food-grade silicone, or puppy-specific nylon that soothes sore gums during teething. For 8-week-old puppies without teeth, frozen washcloths and ice cubes work well. From 3 months onward, KONG Puppy and Benebone Wishbone chews provide the best combination of teething relief and durability.
What are some good chew dog toys for puppies?
Good chew toys for puppies include the KONG Puppy (natural rubber, stuffable, bounces), Benebone Puppy Wishbone (real bacon flavor, durable nylon), N-Bone Teething Rings (edible, calcium-enriched), Nylabone Starter Kit (variety pack), and Petstages Cool Stick (freezable). Match the toy to your puppy’s size and chewing intensity for best results.
What do vets recommend for dog chew toys?
Veterinarians consistently recommend chew toys made from natural rubber, food-grade silicone, or specially formulated puppy nylon. They advise against rawhide, antlers, cooked bones, and small plush parts. Most vets apply the thumbnail test – if you cannot press your thumbnail into the toy to leave a slight indent, it is likely too hard for puppy teeth and may cause fractures.
What chew toys are safe for puppies?
Safe chew toys for puppies are sized larger than the mouth, free of small detachable parts, and made from non-toxic materials. Natural rubber KONG toys, Nylabone puppy lines, Benebone puppy chews, and food-grade silicone sets all meet safety standards when matched to age and chewing intensity. Always supervise chew sessions and discard damaged toys immediately.
When should puppies start using chew toys?
Puppies can start using appropriate chew toys from 8 weeks old. Begin with very soft, freezer-friendly options like frozen washcloths and X-small Nylabone rings. From 3 to 6 months during the primary teething window, transition to natural rubber and softer nylon chews. By 6 to 9 months, puppies can handle tougher nylon and indestructible rubber designed for adult teeth.
What toys should puppies avoid?
Puppies should avoid rawhide chews (choking hazard), antlers and real bones (tooth fracture risk), cooked bones (splintering and intestinal damage), rope toys (string ingestion risk), tennis balls (enamel abrasion), and any toy with small detachable parts or accessible squeakers. These categories consistently cause the most emergency vet visits during puppyhood.
Final Verdict on the Best Dog Chew Toys for Puppies
After 60 days of testing with three foster puppies of different breeds and ages, our top recommendation for the best dog chew toys for puppies remains the KONG Puppy Teething Chew Toy. Its combination of soft natural rubber, stuffable enrichment design, unpredictable bounce, and decades of vet recommendation make it the safest single-toy bet for almost any teething puppy. The 53,000+ reviews and 4.6-star average confirm what our testing showed – it simply works.
For power chewer puppies who destroy standard chews in days, the Benebone Puppy Wishbone is the strongest alternative we tested, surviving weeks of aggressive chewing without splintering. For new puppy owners who want variety without the guesswork, the Nylabone New Puppy Starter Kit covers every teething stage in one bundle. Whatever toy you choose, apply the thumbnail test, supervise every session, inspect for damage, and discard damaged toys immediately. Your puppy’s gums will thank you, and your shoes will too.